Uncover suspenseful storytelling with our collection of mystery VHS tapes. From classic whodunits and detective adventures to atmospheric crime dramas and cult suspense films, these vintage releases capture the intrigue and tension of retro movie nights.
Save 10%
Keystone Crypt
Sleepy Hollow VHS 1999 Horror Special Edition Paramount Pictures
Sale price$4.94
Regular price$5.49
Only 1 unit leftSave 10%
Keystone Crypt
Mysterious Death of Nina Chereau VHS 1990 Thriller Maude Adams Cabin Fever
Sale price$8.09
Regular price$8.99
Only 1 unit leftSave 10%
Keystone Crypt
The Night Stalker VHS 1995 Horror Mystery MCA Universal Darren McGavin
Sale price$4.94
Regular price$5.49
Only 1 unit leftSave 10%
Keystone Crypt
Legend of Sleepy Hollow VHS 1996 Animated Fantasy Disney Favorite Stories
Sale price$3.14
Regular price$3.49
Only 1 unit leftSave 15%
Keystone Crypt
Stargate VHS 1995 Sci-Fi Kurt Russell James Spader Live Entertainment
Sale price$3.82
Regular price$4.49
Only 1 unit leftSave 20%
Keystone Crypt
Ghost VHS 1990 Romantic Drama Original Release Paramount Pictures
Sale price$3.59
Regular price$4.49
Only 1 unit leftSave 20%
Keystone Crypt
Arsenic and Old Lace VHS 1944 Classic Comedy Original Release MGM/UA
Sale price$2.79
Regular price$3.49
Only 1 unit leftSave 20%
Keystone Crypt
Charade VHS 1963 Drama Mystery Original Release Metacom Audrey Hepburn
Sale price$3.99
Regular price$4.99
Only 1 unit leftSave 20%
Keystone Crypt
Anastasia VHS 1986 Drama 2-Part Set Cabin Fever Entertainment
Sale price$3.19
Regular price$3.99
Only 1 unit left
Keystone Crypt
The Mirror Crack'd VHS 1980 Mystery Agatha Christie Lumiere Republic
Sale price$3.29
Only 1 unit left
Keystone Crypt
Shattered Silence VHS 1992 Thriller Mystery Platinum Productions
Sale price$3.99
Only 1 unit left
Keystone Crypt
The Red Violin VHS 1998 Drama Mystery Original Release Lions Gate Films
Sale price$3.49
Only 1 unit left
Keystone Crypt
Lady Ice VHS 1987 Action Crime Thriller Original Release UTA
Sale price$3.99
Only 1 unit leftSave 40%
Keystone Crypt
Vintage Young Sherlock Mystery of the Manor House VHS Set 3 Volumes Boxed 1977
Sale price$5.39
Regular price$8.99
Only 1 unit leftSave 40%
Keystone Crypt
Lot Of 2 Inspector Morse British Detective Mystery VHS Sets #2 & #3
Sale price$25.50
Regular price$42.50
Only 1 unit left
Keystone Crypt
Stir of Echoes VHS 1999 Horror Kevin Bacon Artisan Home Entertainment
Sale price$3.99
Only 1 unit left
Keystone Crypt
Hear No Evil VHS 1993 Thriller Original Release Twentieth Century Fox
Sale price$5.95
Only 1 unit left
Keystone Crypt
Out of the Rain VHS 1991 Thriller Original Release Avid Entertainment
Sale price$7.95
Only 1 unit left